
![]() | This article is sponsored by Marlow Navigation, your premier global provider of full-scale crew and ship management services. |
(www.MaritimeCyprus.com)Â RightShip has released Revision 4.0 of its Dry Bulk Vessel Vetting Baseline Criteria, effective October 1, 2026. This release goes far beyond minor threshold adjustments, it represents a complete structural rewrite aimed at providing explicit baseline expectations, review triggers, and strict resolution requirements.
What Changed in Version 4 vs. Previous Versions?
Compared to earlier versions, Version 4 significantly expands both the scope of governed vessels and the depth of evaluation.

Core Area Comparison Table ("Version 4 at a Glance")
Below is the detailed comparison table mapping key operational areas, specific Version 4 updates, practical significance, and overall operational impact:

Detailed Breakdown of Critical Changes
1. Granular Port State Control (PSC) Rules
Under Criteria 2–9, counting total detentions is no longer sufficient. RightShip evaluates deficiency profiles, severity trends, and close-out quality:
3+ Detentions in 24 Months: Results in an automatic Unacceptable rating.
2 Detentions in 24 Months: Triggers a formal review where approval depends on severity, deficiency profile, and close-out completeness.
1 Detention in 12 Months: Under review with no positive recommendation given until fully closed out.
High-Risk Deficiencies (Criterion 7): Open high-risk deficiencies (structural/mechanical issues) render the vessel Unacceptable until rectified.
Close-Out Assessment (Criterion 9): Every PSC deficiency in the last 12 months requires a formal close-out package containing a detailed Root Cause Analysis (RCA), immediate corrective actions, and systemic preventative measures.
Â
2. Restructured Incident Criteria & Fleet Recurrence
Criteria 10–13 separate incidents by severity and timeframe:
Category A & B Incidents: Assessed over a rolling 24-month window. Having 2 or more Category A incidents within 24 months results in an Unacceptable rating unless non-fault is conclusively proven.
Category C & D Incidents: Tracked over a rolling 12-month window.
SMS & Fleet Recurrence: Repeated incidents across a fleet managed by the same DOC holder indicate Safety Management System (SMS) failures, exposing the entire managed fleet to additional scrutiny or DOC-level reviews.
3. Updated Inspection Age Triggers
Under Criterion 16, vessels meeting or exceeding the age threshold without a valid, acceptable RightShip inspection will be marked Unacceptable:
11+ years: Effective July 1, 2026
10.5+ years: Effective January 20, 2027
4. Zero Tolerance for Missing Platform Metadata (Criterion 1)
If key details—such as Vessel Name, IMO Number, DOC Holding Company, Classification Society, Flag State, or P&I Club—are marked as "Unknown" or omitted on the RightShip platform, the vessel is automatically assigned an Unacceptable rating. Clearance is withheld until details are updated and verified against primary source evidence.
5. Accelerated MoC / VTOP Timeline (Criteria 45 - 46)
When taking over a vessel or changing the DOC holder, operators previously had 3 months to submit the Management of Change (MoC) / Vessel Take Over Process (VTOP) questionnaire. Version 4 compresses this window to 1 month post-delivery/change.
What Shipowners & Managers Need to Know
Vetting Extends Beyond the Individual Ship: RightShip increasingly evaluates the DOC Company and Technical Manager. Repeated PSC detentions, unresolved incidents, or human rights issues on one vessel can trigger fleet-wide reviews or DOC Company Management Assessments.
Close-Outs Demand Systematic Analysis: RightShip routinely rejects basic responses like "crew retrained". A valid close-out package must include:
Comprehensive event description.
Methodological Root Cause Analysis (RCA).
Onboard corrective actions.
Fleet-wide preventative action plans (CAPA).
Data Accuracy is Paramount: Administrative errors or missing platform details can halt chartering operations instantly under Criterion 1.
Action Plan for Operational Readiness
To maintain commercial clearance under Version 4, operators should complete these steps:
Audit Static Data Immediately: Log into the RightShip platform and verify that all vessel details (DOC company, Flag, Class, P&I Club) are accurately listed and supported by up-to-date documentation.
Audit PSC & Incident Records: Review PSC deficiencies from the last 12 months and incidents (Category A/B over 24m; C/D over 12m) to confirm that formal RCA close-outs have been submitted to and approved by RightShip.
Pre-Plan Dry-Docking and Inspections: Factor the updated inspection age thresholds (11 years from July 2026; 10.5 years from Jan 2027) into survey schedules to request inspections well before reaching the threshold age.
Prepare MoC / VTOP Procedures in Advance: Establish standard procedures to complete and submit VTOP questionnaires within the compressed 1-month window following any vessel takeover or DOC transfer.
Register with DBCE: Ensure your management organization is registered with the Dry Bulk Centre of Excellence (DBCE) to meet Criterion 53 requirements.
The RightShip Vetting Criteria Version 4 can be downloaded below:
Source: RightShip
For more Articles and Guidance papers on Rightship, Click HERE
Â























